A brave young father from Arviat on the northwest coast of Hudson Bay was killed yesterday evening by a polar bear while trying to protect his children.
Aaron Gibbons, 31, was the nephew of Gordy Kidlapik, who follows this blog and my twitter account. Gordy has often sent me useful local information and perspectives from Arviat, which is in Nunavut (north of Churchill, Manitoba).
It was heartbreaking to hear this news firsthand from Gordy:
More below and to follow as further details emerge. My sincere condolences to Gordy and his family – what a horrific loss.
UPDATE: 4 July 2018 9:00 pm PT. See correction below regarding the last fatal WHB attack, which was in 1999 (Rankin Inlet), not 1983 as my original title read. My apologies but as you’ll see, the newspaper didn’t get it right either.
Bob Weber, from The Canadian Press, wrote today (4 July 2018, via CTV News):
RCMP say Aaron Gibbons, 31, was on an island about 10 kilometres from the hamlet of Arviat, along the west coast of Hudson Bay, on Tuesday afternoon when the bear attacked.
“He was enjoying his day with his children,” said Gordy Kidlapik, Gibbons’s uncle. “They were surprised by a bear that had started to stalk or charge toward one of his children.
“What (Aaron) did was he told his children to run away to the boat while he was putting himself between the bear and his children to protect them.”
The children, described as elementary school age, made it safely to the boat. One of the girls called for help on the CB radio.
“We actually heard the call for help,” said Kidlapik. “It was terrible to listen to.”
Gibbons was pronounced dead at the scene.
Kidlapik said his nephew would have had a rifle with him.
“That island, you know, it’s one of the places where there will be bears. It’s normal to walk around with a rifle.”
RCMP said Gibbons didn’t have his rifle immediately to hand when the bear attacked.
They said the bear was shot and killed by other adults on what is known as Century Island.
Kidlapik said many in the hamlet stood on the beach Tuesday night under the midnight sun as Gibbons’s body was brought home.
“It’s a very big shock,” he said.
“There’s never been a mauling this serious since I started going out. It’s the first mauling that I know of.”
Correction: The article says the last fatal attack in the region occurred to the north of Arviat, near Rankin Inlet, in the year 2000 [my eyes must have slid right over this sentence without it sinking in!]:
“Dan Pimentel of Nunavut’s Environment Department said the last fatal polar bear mauling was in 2000 near Rankin Inlet, about 200 kilometres up the coast from Arviat.”
However, according to news reports at the time, that is incorrect: the date of the attack near Rankin Inlet was Friday 9 July 1999, which makes it similar in regards to time of year as the attack yesterday outside Arviat. The 1999 victim was Hattie Amitnak, a 64-year-old Baker Lake woman, who was mauled to death while trying to stop the 250-pound bear from attacking her companions, Moses Aliyak, 66, and his 12-year-old grandson, Cyrus Aliyak.
In fact, the last known Prior to 1999, a fatal attack also occurred in the fall of 1983 in Churchill, more than three decades ago, when a much later than usual freeze-up of the sea ice after a lacklustre spring feeding season left many hungry polar bears desperate for food. 1983 was one of the worst years for polar bear problems in Churchill since records began in the 1960s (see details here), although a “zero-tolerance” for bears in Churchill after a serious 2013 Hallowe’en night (November 1) mauling in town has skewed recent tallies of captured problem bears.
The 2013 mauling was blamed on a bear starving due to global warming, even though there is no evidence that was the case. Some people implied that freeze-up was late that fall (even though the average freeze-up date in the 1980s was 8 November, which is also when freeze-up occurred in 2017), or that most bears had come off the ice in poor condition due to an early breakup of the ice in 2013, which was simply not true.
That said, there are always some bears that don’t get enough to eat in spring because they lack hunting experience or cannot compete effectively with bigger, stronger bears – elderly and young bears 3-5 years old often struggle to get the food they need in spring, which is why starvation is the leading cause of death for polar bears (Amstrup 2003; Stirling 2011).
Some bears may have came ashore a bit earlier than usual in the northern portion of Western Hudson Bay this year because of the particular pattern of ice breakup but that does not mean the bear involved in this incident was starving.
We need to wait until information is released on the bear’s condition before any assumptions are made that this fatal mauling was due to a bear starving because of climate change.
Polar bears are always looking for food even when they are fat and healthy.
Gordy’s impression was that the bear was fearless in its approach and he had some strong words about tour operators around Churchill that let tourists get close to bears:
About Churchill Wild tours that Gordy refers to above:
“You will explore the Arctic landscape daily on foot with professional guides, in search of polar bears, although you may not have to go far! Our large picture windows showcase panoramic views of Hudson Bay, and polar bears do venture right up to both the windows and the Lodge fences.” [my bold]
Whether or not habituation of bears to people contributed to this attack, it is still a tragedy for the family and the community involved. See this most recent CBC account from late today (4 July 2018).
Amstrup, S.C. 2003. Polar bear (Ursus maritimus). In Wild Mammals of North America, G.A. Feldhamer, B.C. Thompson and J.A. Chapman (eds), pg. 587-610. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
Stirling, I. 2011. Polar Bears: The Natural History of a Threatened Species. Fitzhenry & Whiteside, Markham.